Saturday, January 30, 2010

When will they ever learn....?

The sun rises and the sun sets, and hurries back to where it rises. The wind blows to  the south and turns to the north; round and round it goes, ever returning on its course. All streams flow into the sea, yet the sea is never full. To the place the streams come from, there they returnagain...  What has been will be again, what has been done will be done again; there is nothing new under the sun. [Ecclesiastes I]

The Iliad and what it can still tell us about war

Echoes of Homer: Operation Achilles, a Nato offensive in Afghanistan in 2007
Photograph: Corporal Adrian Harlen/PA Images






The Trojan war – a more or less mythical event – was a 10-year siege of the city of Troy by a coalition of Greeks, its purpose to restore Helen to her Spartan husband, Menelaus.

The Iliad charts not the famous causes of the conflict (the Trojan prince Paris's abduction of Helen) nor its ­spectacularly bloody end (the Greeks' ruse of the wooden horse and the brutal sacking of the city). Instead, the subject of the poem is menis, fury – specifically, the wrath of the Greeks' best warrior, Achilles.....

The Iliad still has much to say about war, even as it is fought today.

It tells us that war is both the bringer of renown to its young fighters and the destroyer of their lives. It tells us about post-conflict destruction and chaos; about war as the great reverser of fortunes. It tells us about the age-old dilemmas of fighters compelled to serve under incompetent superiors. It tells us about war as an attempt to protect and preserve a treasured way of life. It tells us, too, about the profound gulf between civilian existence and life on the front line; about atrocities and indiscriminate slaughter; about war's peculiar mercilessness to women and children; about friendships and sympathies across the battle lines. It tells us of the love between soldiers who fight together.

Most of all, it tells us about the frightful losses of war: of a soldier losing his closest companion, of a father losing his son....

One of its most arresting characteristics, however, is the way it casts us forward and back, hinting at both a lost, peaceful world "back home", and the horrors of the post-conflict world to come. This is a quality that does much to lend the poem its pathos, and its constant sense of loss. ....

It is perhaps in the relationships between the combatants that modern soldiers might most readily see their own emotions mirrored.

In his book Achilles in Vietnam: Combat Trauma and the Undoing of Character, American psychiatrist Jonathan Shay finds parallels between the pathologies of ­Vietnam veterans whom he has treated, and Homer's Achilles. He argues that Achilles is suffering from what we would now call combat trauma, the death of Patroclus causing his character fatally to unravel.

In particular, Shay compares the comradeship and passionate loyalty of American soldiers in Vietnam to that between Achilles and Patroclus – who grew up together, fought alongside each other, and whose relationship is the subject of some of Homer's most tender writing. In book 16 ....

Former Guardian war reporter Audrey Gillan....in 2008 spoke to soldiers from the Princess of Wales's Royal Regiment who had been involved in a particularly brutal firefight in Basra four years earlier. Lance Corporal Martin Hill remembered the end of a fellow soldier: "He was dead. You could see his skin changing colour and his eyes were dilated. We went through every emotion possible then. Blokes were screaming out and crying."

This is a long way from ramrod backs and stiff upper-lips.

Shay records one of his patients recalling his own fury: "I really loved fucking killing, couldn't get enough. For every one of them I killed I felt better. Made some of the hurt went away [sic]. Every time you lost a friend it seemed like a part of you was gone. Get one of them to compensate what they had done to me. I got very hard, cold, merciless. I lost all my mercy."

The Iliad is a cavalcade of loss, an endless ­parade of men summoned briefly to life only to be consigned to death....

[But] life does have meaning in The Iliad, a meaning that is bound up both with a warrior's kleos, the glory he achieves in the field, and, paradoxically, with a hero's willing, onward surge towards death.

How are we, then, to read the poem amid the horrors and contradictions of our own wars, conflicts that have destroyed countless Andromaches and Astyanaxes?

Bleak as The Iliad is, it is made all the bleaker by its divine characters. The poem's gods, who urge on the fighters and intervene to help their favoured heroes, are flimsy and flippant compared to their mortal counterparts, a source of troubling light relief rather than profundity. The life-and-death struggles of the human characters seem weightier and more agonisingly present when set against the meaningless existence of the gods.

This is a hard world: the war isn't "for" anything, certainly not some greater good, but is merely part of the blind workings of an inexplicable fate that even Zeus, king of the gods, must bow to.

When the warriors die, there are no flights of angels to sing them to their rest, only the prospect of a ghastly, ghostly, absence of meaning....

Who Knew? Canadian Bad Guys

All this has been news to me. Canadian Mining Corps = 60% of the world's mines? Run by such sweethearts as we read about below? I guess I missed a story that should have been on the front pages of the news sources I check out regularly.

Canada’s Long Road to Mining Reform
Written by Cyril Mychalejko
Thursday, 21 January 2010

Rape. Murder. Corruption. Environmental contamination. Impunity. These are just some of the charges and incidents that have plagued Canadian mining operations abroad for years. Now one Canadian lawmaker has taken on the Herculean challenge of legislating mining reform in a country that has traditionally acted like a parent in denial.

Sixty percent of the world’s mining corporations come from Canada. According to a report by InfoMine, Canadian mining corporations listed on the Toronto Stock Exchange had 1,010 projects in South America, 578 in Mexico, 703 in Africa, 376 in Asia and 345 in Australia, New Zealand and Papua New Guinea in 2009. Canada also accounts for 19 percent of global mining exploration spending, which totaled at $13.2 billion. Gold, silver, copper and nickel are among the minerals the industry scours the globe for. In Canada the industry employs 193 registered lobbyists.

"The mining industry in Canada is too powerful a lobby," said Liberal Member of Parliament (MP) John McKay.

McKay’s bill, C-300, would empower the Canadian federal government to investigate complaints of human rights and environmental abuses leveled against mining companies. If the Ministers investigating a company find it guilty of violating social and environmental standards laid out in the bill, the company, if receiving support from the Canada Pension Plan or Export Development Canada could lose funding from the respective organizations.

"It’s limited, but a positive step forward overall," said Sakura Saunders, editor of www.ProtestBarrick.net, a website that provides research and organizing information around mining issues, with a focus on Canadian Mining giant Barrick Gold. "But this bill is simply putting ethical guidelines on the investment and promotion of mining, oil and gas projects in developing countries. It treats the Canadian government as an investor rather than a government."....

Amnesty International issued a public statement on December 9, 2009 revealing that local police at the same mine in Papua New Guinea violently evicted local families and burned down and destroyed at least 130 buildings and houses. Barrick initially denied the allegations, but after the conclusions of Amnesty’s local investigation were released the company was forced to accept the findings.

Barrick was also recently accused of failing to comply with environmental standards in Chile and of anti-union discrimination in Argentina.

On November 27, 2009 another Canadian company made headlines when a Chiapan anti-mining organizer, Mariano Abarca Roblero, was assassinated. One employee and two former employees of Calgary-based Blackfire Exploration Ltd. were arrested for the murder. Other local anti-mining activists have also reported receiving death threats. Documents were later released revealing that the company was bribing the local mayor.

"We have obtained documents - which Blackfire admits are genuine - that clearly show payments of US$1,000 a month going directly into the Mayor of Chicomuselo’s bank account on the understanding that municipal authorities would keep community members opposed to the mine under control," explained Rick Arnold, coordinator for Common Frontiers-Canada. 

Less than a month later, two anti-mining activists were killed in El Salvador within a week of each other, where Canada’s Pacific Rim Mining Co. has been facing resistance to a proposed gold and silver mine in the area. The company is currently using a US-based subsidiary and provisions in the Central American Free Trade Agreement to sue El Salvador’s government for refusing to grant the company permission to commercialize the potentially destructive El Dorado mine....

Copper Mesa Mining Corp. (formerly Ascendant Copper). was also accused of using paramilitaries to intimidate local anti-mining community members. Copper Mesa, along with the Toronto Stock Exchange, are now being sued by three local Ecuadorians.

Finally, the Honduran government is investigating claims that Canada´s Goldcorp Inc. contaminated the Siria Valley with toxic heavy metals from its San Martin mine, which local villagers and NGO's claim has caused health problems with the local population and killed livestock. The Guardian reports that two studies from scientists at Newcastle University supports the complaints against the mining company.... It should be noted that Goldcorp supported the coup that removed President Manuel Zelaya by busing workers to pro-coup marches.

And these are just a few recent incidents, with more operations across the globe, from Burma (Myanmar) to Guatemala, drawing the ire of human rights and environmental activists, as well as the effected communities....

In light of this bloody history, one of the C-300 bill’s shortcomings is that it would not stop mining companies found guilty of abuses from continuing their operations. It would just take away one slice of their funding.

Alexis Stoumbelis, Executive Director of the Committee in Solidarity with the People of El Salvador (CISPES) has a harsher assessment of the bill. She points out that it does nothing to address the unjust global political and economic system which allows countries like Canada to exploit other nations, their people, and its resources with impunity.

"The idea of corporate social responsibility is a weak framework, in my opinion, because it doesn’t fundamentally change the balance of power. Under the current neoliberal model, the right of a corporation to make a profit is upheld over the rights of an individual or a community to have safe water and land on which to farm," [she said.]

In 2007 the Canadian government created roundtable sessions with representatives from the mining industry and activists and academics from civil society to address the lack of oversight for an industry with an infamous global reputation of human rights abuses and environmental destruction.

Two years later, the result of the roundtable’s recommendations was the creation of an oversight mechanism that allows an "independent" corporate social responsibility (CSR) counselor to investigate allegations against mining companies -- but only if the accused company gives consent to be investigated. 

The appointed "independent" investigator, Marketa Evans, who just happens to be "founding director of the University of Toronto's Munk Centre – named for and funded by Peter Munk, founder of Canada's Barrick Gold," answered critics of the policy masquerading as reform by telling The Toronto Star that "My hypothesis is that companies will want to participate in a review."

Currently, the conservative Harper government believes Bill C-300 is unnecessary, and is looking to maintain the status quo. Trade Minister Stockwell Day said at a press conference on January 13 more voluntary standards coupled with shareholder pressure is all that is needed.

"One of the compelling factors that exists today is the very awareness that can be so easily transmitted if a company seems to be going offside in some area, shareholders demand that," said Day. "There is very little tolerance among shareholders for wrong practices."....

MiningWatch Canada, a Canadian non-profit committed to aiding mining reform efforts, responded by pointing out, "Collectively, the voluntary guidelines proposed by the Government of Canada do not reflect, nor do they ensure respect for, all international human rights norms and practices that may be affected by Canadian mining companies operating abroad." 

Yet Canada´s powerful mining lobby is still fighting back. Canadian law firm McCarthy Tetrault´s answer to Bill C-300 was a veiled threat by suggesting that if Bill C-300 passes it would "encourage mining companies to locate in jurisdictions with less regulation, and no commitment to CSR efforts." 

Vince Borg, a spokesperson for Barrick Gold, also responded to allegations presented before parliament in November. "The hearings have amply demonstrated how Bill C-300 has become a magnet for false and unsubstantiated allegations from individuals anywhere in the world and do nothing but unduly harm the Canadian mining industry," said Borg.

Protest Barrick’s Saunders... pointed out one glaring lie where Barrick claimed that "there is no evidence" that there has been "serious human health impacts or even deaths" associated with a toxic spill that occurred last May in Tanzania.

Within three weeks of the spill, major papers in the country reported that at least 20 people and 300 cows had died. Up to this day, villagers still suffer from skin diseases and plant and animal death.

"Bill C300] has a very slim chance of passing, but the heightened public awareness of the bad behavior of Canadian mining companies abroad that media coverage of the bill has brought could help," added Saunders. "But perhaps what’s best about the bill is that the debate around C-300 has exposed the inner workings and relationship of the Canadian government with the mining industry."

It’s expected that the bill will receive another parliamentary reading in March, when it would have to be voted out of committee. It would then need Senate approval, with uniform opposition expected from the country’s ruling Conservative majority making it highly unlikely.

The campaign supporting Bill C-300 has overshadowed a stronger legislation, the International Protection and Promotion of Human Rights Act, or Bill C-354. Proposed by New Democratic Party (NDP) MP Peter Julian, the bill would allow foreigners to sue Canadian companies in Canadian courts for human rights abuses, regardless of where the abuses take place. It replicates the United States' Alien Tort Claims Act, which survivors of torture in other countries have used to sue their torturers in US courts.'
........................

Sadly, hardly any private members' bills ever make it into the law books.

Monday, January 11, 2010

Our dear Leader & the Judiciary

For some reason, despite the silence of the media on the subject, I haven't managed to forget the horror of Il Duce's claming through his peach-fuzzed parliamentary secretary, Pierre Poilievre that,
"Any decision to ask for Mr. Khadr's return to Canada is a decision for the democratically elected government of Canada and not for the courts."
 and
"In Ottawa, government lawyers told the nine high court justices that Canada has done enough to protect Khadr's rights and the courts could not meddle in issues of foreign affairs."
 Apart from the disgraceful fact that American soldiers were killing foreign citizens in a country they were not
at war with, I see no reason why Omar Khadr - if indeed he did throw a grenade at a soldier, which is highly questionable - should not have been within his rights to defend himself in such a situation. That in itself keeps me awake at nights gnashing my teeth. (Of course, since I'm already a night owl, it isn't surprising that I'm awake at all hours - but enough about Moi!)

What raises my blood pressure to the boiling point is Harpoons' continuing evisceration of the Parliamentary system of Government, the disdain for parliamentary tradition, the refusal to honour the spirit of the law.... Anything else? 

Yes, as a matter of fact, the ignorance, sometimes the wilful ignorance of Canadians - especially right wing Canadians - to hold the Government's feet to the fire, rather than ignoring or worshiping everything the Neo-cons do - brings froth to my lips.

It's time for all good people to refresh their memories, assuming they ever knew, the lessons on the Canadian Parliamentary System of Government written by the acknowledged and unsurpassed expert on the subject, the late Professor Eugene Forsey. Fortunately, his document "How Canadians Govern Themselves" is available online at no cost.

A few words from Forsey should raise the ire of every believer in responsible government:
 "The independence of the judiciary is even more important in Canada than in Britain, because in Canada the Supreme Court interprets the written constitution, and so defines the limits of federal and provincial powers."
~ Eugene Forsey ~
Why have the media not gone to town on this fact? Presumably, they have arrogated to themselves the privilege of informing Canadians of the issues we need to consider. Let's put this question to as many of them as we can!!

Wednesday, January 6, 2010

The new best friends in Yemen

Thanks to the Christmas So-called Bomber, we cannot fly to the US with checked baggage and may soon be subjected to body scanning... Just as we can no longer carry water bottles because of a previous idiotic attempt on an aircraft, just as we have to remove our shoes at "Security", just as we have security at all.....

How close did the "bomber" come to achieving his objective? About as close as previous zealots have - that is, not at all. See: http://www.rnw.nl/english/article/how-close-did-christmas-plane-bomber-get 

"It appears that this latest attempt had little chance of success. An expert tells NRC: “ Most explosives have to be packed under pressure for an explosion to take place. That was not so in this case. Eighty grams of PETN burns up in a second.”"

But as a result of this doomed act of terrorism, the US is about to open yet another front in order to help out a "vital counter-terrorism partner"....

Gee, I didn't realise the US were partners with - of all countries - Yemen!!

It appears that others didn't realise it, either....

Russia, China keep toehold in Yemen
By Thalif Deen

NEW YORK - Russia has stolen a march over the United States in the multimillion-dollar arms market in cash-strapped Yemen, whose weapons purchases are being funded mostly by neighboring Saudi Arabia.

The Yemeni armed forces, currently undergoing an ambitious modernization program worth an estimated $4 billion US, are equipped with weapons largely from Russia, China, Ukraine, eastern Europe and the former Soviet republics.

With the attempted bombing of a US airliner on Christmas Day by a Nigerian student, reportedly trained by al-Qaeda in Yemen, the administration of President Barack Obama has pledged to double Yemen’s military and counter-terrorism aid, to nearly $150 million, to strengthen the besieged government of President Ali Abdullah Saleh. 

Yemen receives assistance under several US-funded programs, including Foreign Military Financing, International Military Education and Training, Non-Proliferation, Anti-terrorism and De-mining, and Combating Weapons of Mass Destruction.

But the proposed military aid to Yemen - all of it gratis - along with US arms supplies, is negligible compared with weapons, military training and technical expertise from non-US sources.....

Dr Paul Holtom, director of SIPRI's Arms Transfers Program, said Russian media have reported that Yemen has signed a deal to buy an estimated $1 billion worth of arms from Moscow (with some reports giving figures as high as $2.5 billion)....


Dan Darling, Europe and Middle East Military Markets analyst at the Connecticut-based Forecast International Inc, a leading provider of market intelligence on the military, said that in terms of primary arms suppliers to Yemen, "almost everything revolves around Russia"....

China provided $200 million worth of armaments, while about $400 million in arms were from a mix of former Soviet republics and eastern European nations (mainly Ukraine, but also Belarus, the Czech Republic and Poland) as well as Italy.

A resource-starved Middle Eastern nation, Yemen has negligible quantities of oil and is categorized as one of the world's poorest countries. The US State Department has described Yemen as "desperately poor" but a "vital counter-terrorism partner"....

Because some dim bulb decided to play at being a terrorist, Canadians are either checking their one bag and thinking about having their private parts on display, or not doing business at all in the US. I'd recommend the latter choice, except that - for many people, it isn't a choice at all. Sure we can always fly to Cuba for some sunshine in February, but too many people who do business in the US have mortgages they need to pay.

I'm fed up. The terrorists are being allowed to win this one, regardless of how hapless they are, by our governments' over-reactions. I'm just not sure why the people we elect to govern us can't see this. Or, maybe they do....